MYSTERY: This week the lovely ladies of Gumshoe Weekly list all the instruments they can play. Who knew they had such talent?! Then we get serious with Jayj teaching us the Alphabet with the unsolved cases in Rochester New York known as The Alphabet Murders. Did you know there was a California Alphabet murderer?! Me Either!! Brianna takes us to Sunny Hawaii to tell us about the mystery that to this day 32 years later has shook it to its core the  case of Lisa Au.  

Gumshoe Weekly

What If God Was One Of Us

MAYHEM: You want it, and we got it. Take this return of the Guestpisodes that we lay at your feet, and listen along and Brianna tells us about a serial killer with a kill count comparable to Jeffrey Dahmer, who you may know as "Jolly Jane." Guest Emily talks about Natalia Barnett, whose story sounds oddly similar to the movie "The Orphan." And JayJ wraps it all up with a frankly horrific recounting of the nightmaric circumstances that took place in St. Joseph&apos;s Catholic Orphanage. Also tune in to hear an update on the Jumanji Saga! TW: Child abuse, graphic violence, rape, sexual assault, neglect, death of children 

I Learned How To Hate, Too

MURDER : This week we learn how much Jayj hates her job and thinks Jon Bernthal is the perfect specimen.  Then she takes us on the bizarre journey of the Papin Sisters.  Brianna tells us the true hero of the  Englewood Colorado police department found in Yogi the Blood hound who helped in the missing / murder case of 5yr old Alie Berrelez.

Heroes Of The Class Division

MAYHEM: The excitement is growing for our upcoming 80th and 100th episodes! To deal with the wait we brought you this episode. I am willing to bet that you haven&apos;t heard about these famous criminals last meals in prison, and afterwards we need you to BOLO for Daphne Westbrook, who was kidnapped and hidden cross country by her father John Westbrook in 2019. Tune in to hear more. 

The Thin Man Diatribe

MYSTERY: On this weeks episode we are exploring some truly baffling disappearances.  Brianna brings us to Toledo Ohio to try and unravel the clues left behind in the wake of Cindy Anderson’s sudden disappearance. And after that whirlwind case get your tissues ready for Jayj to tell us of two Kansas parents whose hard working son Randy Leach disappeared from a graduation party. Was it satanic panic, unfortunate incident, or the beginning of a new life. Join us as we swap theories back and forth. 

Freaking Solve It Then

MYSTERY: Throw that ass in a circle and end it at this episode. It&apos;s time you heard about the Grinch&apos;s fingers, the various crimes committed by the FBI&apos;s Most Wanted Adam Emery, and a small collection of cold cases from the great state of Kansas!Before you listen! This episode was recorded on a tricky little laptop that wanted to do it&apos;s own mystery, by omitting some of the words we recorded. So here they are, plug them in to collect all the clues: Scissor, Scissor, 1993, 6&apos;1, Interstate 70, Found in her apartment. 

LUDA'!

MYSTERY:  This week Brianna  tells us the about the horrific Bomber/ Sniper Joseph  Paul Franklin who went on a race fueled killing spree from 1976-1980. JayJ takes us on a journey to find the most missing man Joseph Crater in New York City. 

Religion: The Gateway Drug

MAYHEM: Join us for our weekly discussion of all things wild and crazy. Brianna presents multpile cases of reincarnation and all of the evidence you need to believe them. Then JayJ digs up more roots of racism dating back to the middle of the Vietnam War and the "Gulf of Tonkin Incident(s)". You better pay close attention to this one!

Gently Ask Me How I Died

MYSTERY:  This week Brianna takes us to Westfield New Jersey where we try and uncover who The Watcher is by sifting through some of their ominous letters.  Jayj then tells us the amazing work the DNA Doe Project is doing by telling us the story of  The Mowry Wetlands Jane Doe, New Britain Jane Doe,  Apache Junction Jane Doe.

Hand, Paper, Knife

MAYHEM: In one of our most chaotic episodes yet, we discuss a family annihilator that you've almost definitely heard of before. After that we present to you a conspiracy involving the government, atomic bombs, and body snatching. It's going to be a bumpy ride. 

Go Forward And Don't Steal Any Bodies

Mystery : This week we question who is making up these "8th Wonders of The World"  and what are our reoccurring dreams telling us about ourselves ?! Then we get down to business with Brianna telling us the real life story of doll behind Hollywood's Annabelle...Annabelle . Then Jayj tells us the  ridiculous covered up  murder of   Gareth Williams an MI6 Spy. 

2 Person Mystery Squad

MURDER/MYSTERY/MAYHEM: In this special episode #70 we discuss the 2015 documentary 'Soaked in Bleach' which is about the mysterious death of American Musical icon Kurt Cobain. Come along as we talk about theories, facts, and the audio recordings captured by the private investigator that was initially hired by Courtney Love to search for Kurt Cobain.

Save The American Icon, Tom!

MURDER: This week we talk about the mind boggling heart breaking  case of Sierah Joughin.  Then Jayj Tells us of the real life story behind Tvs Dexter, Pedro Rodrigues Filho.

Macaroni & Cheese Idiot

MURDER: This week is particularly blood filled and haunting as we tell you about a true female Dracula: Erzebet Bathory; and the entirely unquantifiable death of Cindy Hack James, who's death was ruled a suicide but we go back and forth over how true that may be. What do you think? 

Incredible Collaging Skills

MAYHEM : HAPPY INAGURATION DAY  GUMSHOE BABIES!! This week Brianna tells us the story of dooms day  believer Lori Vallow whose children went missing in 2020.  Then Jayj gives us the science lesson we didn't know we all needed along with a quick pop culture of Alchemy. 

Hunky Monkey List

Join two amateur sleuths as we dive face-first into mysteries great and small, murderous and mythical, "attempting" to seek out the truth each week.